Affiliate Disclosure: MattressPicks earns a commission when you purchase through our links at no extra cost to you. We research each mattress independently.
A decade ago, buying a mattress meant going to a showroom. Today, the majority of mattresses are sold online. Both channels have real advantages — and real pitfalls. Here’s an honest breakdown of where to get the best mattress for your money.
The Case for Buying Online
The online mattress revolution exploded around 2014 with brands like Casper, Tuft & Needle, and Leesa offering direct-to-consumer mattresses in a box. By cutting out retail overhead, these brands offered genuine quality at significantly lower prices.
- ✅ Lower prices — no retail markup
- ✅ Risk-free trials (90–365 nights)
- ✅ Convenient home delivery
- ✅ Easy to compare reviews and specs
- ✅ Wide selection without geographic limits
- ✅ Often free returns and pickup
- ❌ Cannot feel the mattress before buying
- ❌ Must wait for delivery
- ❌ Some brands are misleading online
- ❌ Returns can be complicated in practice
- ❌ No immediate help from a sales expert
The Case for Buying In-Store
Brick-and-mortar mattress stores still account for roughly 40% of mattress sales. Their primary advantage is the ability to try before you buy — a legitimate benefit when spending $1,000+ on something you’ll sleep on for a decade.
- ✅ Try before you buy
- ✅ Immediate expert guidance
- ✅ Take home same day (sometimes)
- ✅ Easier returns for immediate issues
- ✅ Financing often available in-store
- ❌ Higher prices due to retail overhead
- ❌ Pushy sales tactics are common
- ❌ Limited selection to what’s in stock
- ❌ Comparison shopping is harder
- ❌ Showroom conditions differ from home use
The “Showrooming” Strategy
A popular approach: visit a store to test mattress types (firm vs. soft, foam vs. innerspring), then buy online. Use the store to identify what feel you want, then find the equivalent model online for less money with a home trial.
Online Mattress Trial Periods: The Great Equalizer
The 100–365 night trial period has largely neutralized the “can’t try it” objection to online buying. You get weeks or months to sleep on the mattress in your actual environment. Most people find this more useful than 5 minutes on a showroom floor in clothes and shoes.
Key trial facts: Nectar offers 365 nights. Saatva and WinkBed offer 365 nights. Helix offers 100 nights. Tuft & Needle offers 100 nights. Most brands cover return pickup at no cost.
When to Buy In-Store
Consider a store if you need a mattress immediately (moving, guest arriving), prefer hands-on guidance, have difficulty with online returns, or have very specific physical needs that are hard to assess without testing.
Our Recommendation
For most shoppers, buying online offers better value, more selection, and equally good return policies. The key is to shop established brands with legitimate trial periods and read independent reviews carefully.
Shop Nectar (365 Night Trial) →
Shop Saatva (365 Night Trial) →